The Acimgate Tapes (or Lollar Files?) have been released.
As far as Alternate Rydell being an insult… has he never been forced to redraft? Has nobody on the Odyssey team told him that an episode of his doesn’t work and needs revision? The number one task of a writer is to kill your darlings, but when someone shows up with another darling separate and distinct from his own, he gets deeply offended? I understand if he thought that by asking for official permission that it might infer a judgment on his story. But has he ever once seen a Star Wars fan pitch an alternate Prequel trilogy, lol? It’s not an indictment on the official canon to allow for alternate versions; and a dramatic reading of a fanfic should not be seen as a threat. He cannot say that Alternate Rydell will take all the glory from official Rydell and then say that Alternate Rydell will never be good enough compared to official Rydell. Fan fiction is a legitimate form of criticism; it’s a redraft, only post-release.
Yeah, after the behavior I’ve seen of him, I don’t think I can hold a reasonable discussion with Phil Lollar. This isn’t merely a civil disagreement between a creator and his fan; this is a childish attempt at gatekeeping. If he cannot allow another variation of his story to exist, then he shouldn’t have published it in the first place. If he feels remotely insecure about official Rydell, he should own up to those feelings. If he doesn’t, he should gladly encourage fans to dream up the optimal version. Whether he does or doesn’t, that behavior was unacceptable.
I don’t believe that giving the 2+2 of what is moral is good for 8-12 year olds, based on my experience with my own life and having taught Sunday School for the past couple months. There’s a difference between relating how complicated situations do happen and teaching confused morality. The episodes or Phil can ask these questions, but not answering them is an answer in of itself.
As for whether arcs stick in our minds or not because moral questions are never answered, I’d point directly to the Three in One arc. Every single episode answers the doubts raised. The arc has clear bad guys and good guys. Yet I still think—and think fondly on, might I add—episodes like Triple Decker Sundae and not Rydell Revelations. I question if Rydell Revelations really encouraged me to think, or if Phil’s interviews on AIOWiki did instead; if so, I’m grateful soley to the interviews where Phil preaches about critical thought for three hours, not the episodes themselves.
As for the rest of the interview, I find it difficult to respond. On one hand, Phil argues that you can’t give 4 over 2 + 2, yet on the other hand tells his interviewer that the 4 he came to is unacceptable. It comes off as though Phil wants to justify wrong-doing, whether that’s his true motive or not notwithstanding.
Exactly! I love that you brought up the 3 in 1 arc. There’s a major difference between that and Rydell and at least imo it’s the moral aspect. Olivia does a whole bunch of things wrong and even Zoe while trying to help Olivia also does some things that I would argue weren’t the best choices but they were shown in a bad light.
Phill definitely seems to be viewing Morris’s wrongdoing as morally good and Emily as having a vendetta against him. But how would you feel if a family member, friend or even you thought you were going to die because of someone else? Forgiveness is way different than trust and there needs to be consequences for people’s actions or our world would be chaotic.
Morrie did attempt murder. Intentions really don’t matter in the end, it’s the actions that accompanied them. This wouldn’t hold up in a court of law.
Intentions VS actions are like this: I could say I intended to help you by hurting you but all you would care about is the fact that in my attempt to help you, I instead hurt you.
Anyways, that was just to add to your thoughts, just fyi. I really think Phill needs to reconsider this. It’s causing me to wonder if I should even support AIO anymore. 🫤 Idt I want my future kids listening to this if I have any. Certainly not Rydell.
What’s the difference between them having to rerelease the Harley episodes because of issues with that and this? I see nothing different. I’d argue this is worse than 1 police officer character portraying officers in a bad light. At least they had officer Ryan. There is no other option cuz now they’re making Suzu bad again. Morrie seems genuine in Realizations but I still don’t trust him. And at least Whit apologized but I still don’t trust him either.
And what about the whole thing of Whit being the perfect one In Odyssey? I’m pretty sure I remember it being said by actual creators and it’s said all throughout Odyssey by numerous characters. Whit always disagrees but until this event, he honestly was the perfect one.
I just don’t get what Phill has a problem with, with our issues and why he won’t just rerelease Rydell. I was so excited when I first listened to it cuz I thought they were gonna rerelease it and use your alternate version. Nathan Hoobler rocks btw! 😂
Why can’t kids consent? If you force a child onto a roller coaster you’re doing them harm. Kids can give consent. What Morrie did to Emily is way worse than forcing a child onto a roller coaster. The real difference between the Imagination station and the escape room is consent. Not to mention Emily’s parents weren’t really involved soooo… And Morrie attempted murder. That’s enough to get him convicted. Whit at least gives you the knowledge of the imagination station beforehand and adults have been in it so they know what to expect and can give their kids the information too. At least they have an option but Emily (and Matthew) weren’t given an option to use the escape room. The door shuts on its own.
The Acimgate Tapes (or Lollar Files?) have been released.
As far as Alternate Rydell being an insult… has he never been forced to redraft? Has nobody on the Odyssey team told him that an episode of his doesn’t work and needs revision? The number one task of a writer is to kill your darlings, but when someone shows up with another darling separate and distinct from his own, he gets deeply offended? I understand if he thought that by asking for official permission that it might infer a judgment on his story. But has he ever once seen a Star Wars fan pitch an alternate Prequel trilogy, lol? It’s not an indictment on the official canon to allow for alternate versions; and a dramatic reading of a fanfic should not be seen as a threat. He cannot say that Alternate Rydell will take all the glory from official Rydell and then say that Alternate Rydell will never be good enough compared to official Rydell. Fan fiction is a legitimate form of criticism; it’s a redraft, only post-release.
Yeah, after the behavior I’ve seen of him, I don’t think I can hold a reasonable discussion with Phil Lollar. This isn’t merely a civil disagreement between a creator and his fan; this is a childish attempt at gatekeeping. If he cannot allow another variation of his story to exist, then he shouldn’t have published it in the first place. If he feels remotely insecure about official Rydell, he should own up to those feelings. If he doesn’t, he should gladly encourage fans to dream up the optimal version. Whether he does or doesn’t, that behavior was unacceptable.
I don’t believe that giving the 2+2 of what is moral is good for 8-12 year olds, based on my experience with my own life and having taught Sunday School for the past couple months. There’s a difference between relating how complicated situations do happen and teaching confused morality. The episodes or Phil can ask these questions, but not answering them is an answer in of itself.
As for whether arcs stick in our minds or not because moral questions are never answered, I’d point directly to the Three in One arc. Every single episode answers the doubts raised. The arc has clear bad guys and good guys. Yet I still think—and think fondly on, might I add—episodes like Triple Decker Sundae and not Rydell Revelations. I question if Rydell Revelations really encouraged me to think, or if Phil’s interviews on AIOWiki did instead; if so, I’m grateful soley to the interviews where Phil preaches about critical thought for three hours, not the episodes themselves.
As for the rest of the interview, I find it difficult to respond. On one hand, Phil argues that you can’t give 4 over 2 + 2, yet on the other hand tells his interviewer that the 4 he came to is unacceptable. It comes off as though Phil wants to justify wrong-doing, whether that’s his true motive or not notwithstanding.
did you like the part where he said that kids can’t even consent as a response to “Emily didn’t consent”
Exactly! I love that you brought up the 3 in 1 arc. There’s a major difference between that and Rydell and at least imo it’s the moral aspect. Olivia does a whole bunch of things wrong and even Zoe while trying to help Olivia also does some things that I would argue weren’t the best choices but they were shown in a bad light.
Phill definitely seems to be viewing Morris’s wrongdoing as morally good and Emily as having a vendetta against him. But how would you feel if a family member, friend or even you thought you were going to die because of someone else? Forgiveness is way different than trust and there needs to be consequences for people’s actions or our world would be chaotic.
Morrie did attempt murder. Intentions really don’t matter in the end, it’s the actions that accompanied them. This wouldn’t hold up in a court of law.
Intentions VS actions are like this: I could say I intended to help you by hurting you but all you would care about is the fact that in my attempt to help you, I instead hurt you.
Anyways, that was just to add to your thoughts, just fyi. I really think Phill needs to reconsider this. It’s causing me to wonder if I should even support AIO anymore. 🫤 Idt I want my future kids listening to this if I have any. Certainly not Rydell.
What’s the difference between them having to rerelease the Harley episodes because of issues with that and this? I see nothing different. I’d argue this is worse than 1 police officer character portraying officers in a bad light. At least they had officer Ryan. There is no other option cuz now they’re making Suzu bad again. Morrie seems genuine in Realizations but I still don’t trust him. And at least Whit apologized but I still don’t trust him either.
And what about the whole thing of Whit being the perfect one In Odyssey? I’m pretty sure I remember it being said by actual creators and it’s said all throughout Odyssey by numerous characters. Whit always disagrees but until this event, he honestly was the perfect one.
I just don’t get what Phill has a problem with, with our issues and why he won’t just rerelease Rydell. I was so excited when I first listened to it cuz I thought they were gonna rerelease it and use your alternate version. Nathan Hoobler rocks btw! 😂
Why can’t kids consent? If you force a child onto a roller coaster you’re doing them harm. Kids can give consent. What Morrie did to Emily is way worse than forcing a child onto a roller coaster. The real difference between the Imagination station and the escape room is consent. Not to mention Emily’s parents weren’t really involved soooo… And Morrie attempted murder. That’s enough to get him convicted. Whit at least gives you the knowledge of the imagination station beforehand and adults have been in it so they know what to expect and can give their kids the information too. At least they have an option but Emily (and Matthew) weren’t given an option to use the escape room. The door shuts on its own.